SSS’s Divine College of Pharmacy, Nampur Road, Satana, Nashik, Maharashtra, India 423301.
Any suggested or necessary changes to a product, procedure, piece of machinery, or system that could have an impact on the product's quality, safety, or compliance usually trigger the Change Control procedure in the pharmaceutical sector. In addition to avoiding potential hazards, this document offers research to guarantee the safety and quality of medications. By examining the patterns and trends that result in non-conformances and quality deviations, this study looks at the underlying causes of occurrences inside the pharmaceutical industry's change control process. In order to reduce interruption, risk, and inefficiencies, it guarantees that all changes—planned or not—are carefully considered, approved, and carried out in a regulated way. The production technique, the quantity of materials used, and the manufacturing location can all change at any point during the product life cycle. In order to minimise possible risks connected with any changes to processes, materials, or systems, maintain product quality, protect patient safety, and assure continuous compliance with regulatory requirements, the pharmaceutical sector needs an efficient change control procedure.
The key component of a quality system that concentrates on managing change to produce a high-quality output by avoiding non-compliance is change control. Change control, as used in an industrial context, is the methodical process of overseeing modifications to systems, procedures, goods, or organizational structures to make sure they are appropriately assessed, approved, carried out, and recorded. This procedure seeks to reduce risks and guarantee that modifications are implemented in a way that preserves operational effectiveness, product quality, safety, and regulatory compliance. In the pharmaceutical sector, change control refers to a series of regulated procedures used to handle adjustments to procedures, systems, or documentation that might affect the safety and quality of products.
The significance of this document lies in its global distribution and risk avoidance.
Scope: The extent to which change control was used:
• Major system changes: It's important to exercise caution when there are major system changes, particularly when such changes may impact the ability of company operations to continue.
• Regulatory and compliance requirements: To prove compliance and keep track of changes, industries with stringent regulations, such as pharmaceuticals, banking, or aviation, frequently need a formalised change control procedure.
• Product changes: It's critical to handle product changes methodically when it becomes necessary to modify a product's features, specs, or design either during development or after it has been first released.
• Process changes: Whenever there are changes to operational procedures or key business processes, it is imperative to implement a change control method, particularly when the objective is to improve efficiency or adjust to new circumstances.
• Modifications to hardware or equipment: It's important to have a systematic procedure in place for any significant modifications to hardware or equipment that might affect the production process or service delivery.
• Modifications to contractual agreements: Care should be taken when it becomes necessary to alter terms, conditions, or other important components of contracts with partners, clients, or suppliers.
• Documentation and policy changes: It's critical to handle documentation and policy updates in a methodical manner if corporate policies, standards, or significant paperwork need to be revised, updated, or even removed.
• Reaction to external factors: Businesses need to be able to react quickly to changes in the market, in consumer tastes, in technology, or in the legal and regulatory environment.
Pharmaceutical Change Control Examples
What does Pharma's Change Control mean?
In the pharmaceutical industry, change control is a methodical procedure that includes meticulous assessment, recording, and approval of modifications to pharmaceutical processes, facilities, equipment, suppliers, documents, change management systems, SOPs, and even employees. The goal of change control is to reduce risk and make sure that any changes are implemented smoothly across the company without compromising the products' efficacy, safety, or quality. Furthermore, change control guarantees that the final product is just as compliant as the original.
Changes often take place in the following areas:
Production
Engineering
R&D
Quality Control
Quality Assurance
Cleaning process
The list above is only indicative and not all-inclusive. To give you a reasonable sense of the extent of the changes in the pharmaceutical manufacturing sector, the list is provided.
Cycle of Change Control:
Step 1– Change originates
Types of Changes:
Changes are broadly divided into two groups:
Unplanned Change:
Unplanned Change is any unforeseen alteration that necessitates quick action. These are typically the consequence of any unanticipated circumstance, such as a malfunctioning piece of equipment, a departure from established protocols, etc.
Anticipated Modification:
A planned change is a deliberate, predetermined alteration or modification that is carried out with the appropriate assessment and approval. Every aspect of safety, effectiveness, and quality is evaluated prior to adoption, and these modifications are well thought out.
Importance of Change Control in the Pharma Industry:
In order to facilitate change inside the organization, change control is crucial on a larger scale. It guarantees that modifications won't result in a decline in efficacy, safety risks, or quality.
Let's take a broader view and recognise how crucial change control is to the pharmaceutical sector.
Regulatory Compliance:
The FDA, EMA, DHA, CDSCO, MHRA, and other regulatory agencies have established a number of national and international compliance standards that pharmaceutical manufacturing companies must follow.
Change control guarantees that the organizations follow cGMP (Good Manufacturing Practices) and the rules established by these agencies.
Risk management:
Change control aids in the early mitigation of risk. It can anticipate the dangers by proactively assessing the impact of the suggested modification. This insight can lessen the impact of hazards on the organization and assist in managing them carefully.
Documentation and Accountability:
The most important step in change control is thorough documenting of every modification. It also entails documenting the decisions taken throughout the appraisal process as well as the reasoning behind the change. For a variety of regulatory reasons, the entire document acts as an open record. By identifying the approving authority, these papers promote organisational responsibility.
Continual Improvement:
The foundation of every suggested organisational reform is improvement. Processes, personnel, equipment, or anything else might be improved. Within pharmaceutical companies, change control facilitates progress in a controlled and methodical manner. When a pharmaceutical company changes a tablet coating machine, for instance, it does so with the goal of providing increased accuracy and efficiency. In addition to producing an updated machine, change control influences (improves) the entire process of upgrading a new machine, including its operating method, materials needed, lead time, resources, SOP, and so on.
Product Consistency:
Change control helps to preserve the quality and consistency of the product. Manufacturing pharmaceuticals is crucial, and even a small alteration might cause the finished product to differ from the expected quality.
Operational Efficiency and Cost Savings:
Businesses may prevent production delays or downtime by methodically managing changes. Additionally, change management may assist prevent product recalls and regulatory fines, safeguarding the company's reputation and financial stability.
Improved Coordination and Communication:
A change control system encourages cooperation and communication across the organization's departments. It guarantees that all departments are informed about the change, its effects, and the methods for putting it into practice.
In order to promote greater communication and collaboration within the organisation for better decision-making, departments can voice their concerns, provide alternatives, or bring up issues as necessary.
Top Techniques for Successful Change Management
Pharmaceutical businesses should take into account the following best practices in order to develop an efficient change control process:
Keep thorough records
Although implementing these best practices is essential, using technology may improve change control management's accuracy and efficiency even further.
Role of QMS Software in Streamlining Change Control Management:
Change control is typically carried out manually utilising paper-based procedures, which results in mistakes, duplication of effort, and delays in informing all parties.
The secret is an Electronic Quality Management System (eQMS) with integrated change control assistance. Software for change control management may centralise all the data in a single system and digitise the whole change process.
In order to achieve compliance, the system assists in recording, managing, reviewing, validating, approving, and updating the modification for all stakeholders.
The Change Control System's primary features are:
• Change Request Initiation: Start and record requests for modifications to systems, documents, or procedures.
• Impact Evaluation: This module assesses how modifications could affect operations, compliance, and processes.
• Automated Workflow: It automates every step of the change management process, from initiating requests to closing them down.
• Cost measurement: Determine the expenses related to the suggested modification in order to assess it.
• Compliance Assurance: By keeping a thorough audit record of all modifications, it guarantees conformity to regulatory requirements.
• Cooperation and Communication: Assist in identifying the departments that will be impacted by the change and notify them of it via alerts and notifications.
• Documentation: Keeps track of all change-related documentation in one place.
• Verification and Closure: Prior to closure, modifications are confirmed to be effective after implementation.
• Training on Changes: determines who need training for the change and arranges for that training.
Process of Change Control:
The following is a list of process assessment flow steps:
1. Start the change request.
2. Assess the impact.
3. Examine the requested change.
4. Approve change request plan.
5. Put Change Into Practice.
6. Provide Training.
7. Track Effectiveness.
1. Start the change request process:
To identify and formally record the proposed change, the first step in the change control process is to complete a change request form or adhere to a specified change control protocol. Change categorisation, such as minor, major, and critical, can be used to execute changes. Company criteria and internal procedures determine the need for change.
2. Assess the impact:
An impact evaluation may be carried out after the change request has been started. This process entails assessing the possible effects of the suggested modification on the efficacy, safety, quality, and regulatory compliance of the product.
3. Examine the requested change:
The modification request is considered by designated individuals with the required credentials.
At this point, all pertinent facts and information are analysed.
4. Approve change request plan:
The responsible party either accepts or rejects the change request plan following the impact analysis and change request review. Following approval of change request plans, documents are securely signed using electronic signatures that comply with 21 CFR Part 11. In order to ensure responsibility and traceability of all actions, users sign papers using distinct identification codes and password combinations.
5. Put Change into Practice:
Following approval, the change plan is carried out in a methodical and controlled way. Verifying sure the appropriate modifications are made to procedures, tools, or documentation is part of putting a change into action. The modification request is then authorised for closure.
6. Provide Training:
Ensure that all parties involved are aware of the new processes, procedures, and changes associated with the transition by providing training. Everyone will understand the change, its goal, and how it will affect their roles and duties if there is effective communication.
7. Track Effectiveness:
Following implementation, the change's effectiveness is tracked and assessed. To assess the impact and subsequent progress, an effectiveness check must be carried out.
Classification:
These processes are typically classified based on nature (the type of change) and impact (the level of consequence it has on the system). Below is a breakdown of this classification:
Based On Nature of Change:
Design Changes:
Nature: Involves modifications to product or process design, including new equipment, components, or layouts.
Impact: Can affect product specifications, production processes, and quality standards.
Examples: Adding new features to a product, changing raw material specifications, or redesigning manufacturing layouts.
Process changes:
Nature: Involves changes to production processes, methods, or workflows, which can include equipment upgrades or process optimization.
Impact: May affect throughput, quality, and safety; often requires training and requalification.
Examples: Upgrading machinery, changing operational parameters (e.g., temperature, pressure), or introducing new process steps.
Technology Changes:
Nature: Changes involving the introduction of new technologies, software, or automated systems.
Impact: Can affect the efficiency, data management, and integration of systems across the organization.
Examples: Implementing new control software, adopting AI for process optimization, or integrating devices.
Regulatory or compliance changes:
Nature: Changes required due to updates in regulatory or industry standards, such as safety codes, environmental requirements, or quality certifications.
Impact: Can result in adjustments to procedures, documentation, and possibly affect product development cycles.
Examples: Adjusting processes to comply with new environmental regulations or industry standards like ISO certification.
Operational Changes:
Nature: Involves shifts in day-to-day operational procedures, schedules, or workforce assignments.
Impact: May affect resource utilization, efficiency, and short-term operational performance. Examples: Changes in work shifts, supply chain alterations, or maintenance schedules.
Based on impact change:
The impact classification focuses on the consequences or significance of a change, especially in terms of its risk to the overall system, operations, or product. It is often categorized as follows:
Major (High Impact) Changes:
Impact: These changes have significant consequences, potentially affecting the entire organization or system. They may involve high risk to product quality, safety, compliance, or business operations.
Examples: Introduction of a new product line, significant process redesign, large-scale technological upgrades, or regulatory non-compliance risks.
Minor (Low Impact) Changes:
Impact: These changes have a limited or localized effect, with minimal disruption to operations. They may involve fine-tuning, process adjustments, or incremental improvements.
Examples: Small updates to existing product specifications, minor equipment adjustments, or administrative changes.
Critical (Severe Impact) Changes:
Impact: These changes are high-risk and must be closely monitored, as they could lead to catastrophic outcomes, including safety hazards, severe product defects, or legal repercussions.
Examples: Removal of a key component from a safety system, drastic alteration in manufacturing protocols that could lead to safety violations.
Standard (Routine) Changes:
Impact: Changes that are routine and generally do not require significant oversight. These are typically part of regular maintenance or operational adjustments.
Examples: Routine maintenance or software updates, minor adjustments to inventory systems, or cosmetic packaging changes.
Standard (Routine) Changes:
Impact: Changes that are routine and generally do not require significant oversight. These are typically part of regular maintenance or operational adjustments.
Examples: Routine maintenance or software updates, minor adjustments to inventory systems, or cosmetic packaging changes.
MATERIALS AND METHOD
Formulation: the proportion of active and inert substances and their makeup.
API: physical attributes, process, new manufacturer, and grade change.
Equipment: a shift in concept and procedure; a change in scale (pilot batch, commercial batch, bio batch).
Equipment schedule, setup, and manual to automated cleaning process changes.
METHODS:
Change Request (CR): Submitting a Change Request (CR) is the initial step in the procedure. A description of the suggested modification, its justification, and its extent are all included in this request.
Modify the classification:
Significant Modifications: These affect the quality, safety, or efficacy of the product and often require regulatory submission or approval (e.g., change in formulation, manufacturing process, or equipment).
Minor Changes: These have a minimal impact on product quality and may not require extensive review or regulatory approval (e.g., adjustment in process parameters).
Emergency Changes: These are necessary to address urgent issues, such as equipment failure or safety concerns, and may require expedited processing.
Effect Assessment: An integral aspect of the change control process is completing an effect assessment. This entails assessing how the suggested modification could affect a number of factors including:
Product Quality: Making sure the modification won't have a detrimental effect on the product's efficacy, safety, or quality.
Assessing whether the modification necessitates regulatory reporting or submission to authorities (such as the FDA or EMA) is known as regulatory compliance.
Supply Chain: Evaluating the potential effects of the modification on production schedules or suppliers.
Cost: Assessing the change's financial effects.
Review and Approval: A Change Control Board (CCB), usually made up of representatives from production, regulatory affairs, quality assurance, and other pertinent departments, reviews the change request and its effect assessment.
The CCB decides whether to approve, reject, or modify the proposed change. They ensure that all critical aspects, including regulatory compliance and risk, are thoroughly considered.
Implementation Plan: If the change is approved, an implementation plan is developed. This includes:
Timeline: A schedule for implementing the change.
Resources: Identification of necessary resources (e.g., materials, equipment, personnel).
Training: Ensuring that employees are trained on any new procedures or systems resulting from the change.
Documentation: Updating SOPs (Standard Operating Procedures), batch records, and other necessary documentation to reflect the change.
Validation and Verification: After implementation, a validation process is carried out to ensure that the change has been successfully integrated and is operating as intended. Testing to ensure product quality is maintained. Data review to confirm that the change produces the expected outcomes.
Documentation and Record Keeping: Throughout the entire change control process, thorough documentation is maintained.
Audit Trails: These records are essential for regulatory inspections and audits to ensure transparency and compliance.
Communication: Communication regarding the change should be clear and transparent, with all impacted departments notified well in advance.
Regulatory Notification: If the change impacts the product in any way (e.g., formulation, packaging, manufacturing location), it may require regulatory notification or approval.
Continuous Improvement: The change control process is an iterative cycle, and the pharmaceutical industry emphasizes continuous improvement. Post-implementation review and feedback loops are critical to ensuring that the organization learns from each change and refines the change control process for future improvements.
Benefits Of Change Control Process:
· Improved Resource Management.
· Enhanced Decision-Making.
· Maintaining Project or System Stability.
· Improved Communication and Collaboration.
· Change control offers a way to anticipate challenges and respond efficiently.
· Identifying Potential Risks.
· Improved Customer Satisfaction.
· Minimizing Downtime and Disruptions.
· Meeting Customer Expectations.
· Tracking Changes Over Time.
· Transparency for Stakeholders.
· Support for Compliance and Regulatory Requirements.
· Cost Control and Budget Management.
· Organizational effectiveness and efficiency is continued.
· Increases revenue of the company.
· Generates an chance for the growth of best practices, Leadership development, and team development.
· Change control offers a way to anticipate challenges and respond efficiently.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The review found that the pharmaceutical industry’s change control process is largely effective in meeting stringent regulatory requirements, such as those from the FDA, EMA, and ICH. Companies consistently apply change control procedures to ensure compliance with Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) and other regulatory guidelines, particularly in areas like documentation, product formulation, and equipment modifications. The process generally includes comprehensive risk assessments to evaluate the potential impact of proposed changes on product quality, patient safety, and regulatory compliance. Changes Phase ensures that any change made in the pharmaceutical industry has been thoroughly evaluated for its effectiveness, compliance, and impact on product quality. It is an essential step in maintaining the integrity of the change control process and ensuring ongoing regulatory adherence and product safety.
The change control process is fundamental to maintaining product quality and regulatory compliance within the pharmaceutical industry. Any modification to processes, equipment, materials, or procedures must be rigorously controlled to avoid compromising the safety, efficacy, or quality of the final product. The need for ongoing research into optimizing change control processes to address emerging challenges, such as globalization of supply chains and new technological innovations, could also be emphasized. It might include recommendations for best practices, such as regular training for staff, adoption of modern technologies, cross-functional collaboration, and a risk-based approach to change evaluation.Future change control processes may become increasingly integrated with other aspects of the Quality Management System (QMS), including Deviation Management, CAPA (Corrective and Preventive Actions), and Audit Trails, creating a more holistic approach to managing quality and compliance.
CONCLUSION:
The Change Control Process is a cornerstone of maintaining product quality, regulatory compliance, and patient safety in the pharmaceutical industry. As the industry faces increasingly complex challenges—including evolving regulatory requirements, technological advancements, and global supply chain dynamics—the need for a robust and adaptive change control system has never been greater. This review highlights the essential role that change control plays in ensuring that any modifications to processes, equipment, materials, or other aspects of pharmaceutical production are thoroughly evaluated, documented, and monitored to mitigate risks and maintain product integrity.
REFERENCES
Rushikesh Sawkar*, Dr. Shivraj Jadhav, Mayur Bhamare, Dr. Sunil Mahajan, A Review on Change Control Process in Pharmaceutical Industry, Int. J. of Pharm. Sci., 2025, Vol 3, Issue 10, 3308-3320 https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17490786
10.5281/zenodo.17490786
